America
Needs a National Health Care System
“You can
always rely on Americans to do the right thing
after they've exhausted every other possibility.”
Winston Churchill
Just about everyone on this planet would agree that health
care is an essential service for all people. And that America
is the richest country in the world. Well, OK. That's not true
anymore. We've slipped to seventh place.
Yet, 47 million Americans cannot afford insurance and 20 thousand
citizens are dying every year because they don't have health
care. That's more than 2.5 times the number of Americans than
have died in Iraq, Afghanistan and 9/11 combined. High premiums
for health insurance are little bother to the rich and well
employed, but the costs can mean life and death to the poor.
Americans pay more for health care than any other industrialized
country, yet its health care system currently ranks 37th in
the world, according to The World Health Organization, and the
other countries provide much better and expansive services.
Our health care system is at the bottom of the list in terms
of the prevention of death through effective medical care.
As President Obama seeks improvement in the nation's health
care system the proponents of a Single-Payer System are making
their voices heard. Their opponents, supporters of our current
Insurance-Based System, are attacking the concept, calling it
Socialized Medicine and a communist plot. Americans need to
understand the fundamental differences in these programs.
A Single-Payer Health Care System is a non-profit
government organization that funds the payment for all doctors,
drugs and hospital costs related to the health care of its citizens.
The system is supported through taxes and the payment system
is streamlined to a single organization that could save American
taxpayers $400 billion a year!
Hospitals and health care providers can be locally owned and
operated and doctors could maintain private practices. The management
decisions for their services will be made by career professionals,
not the bean counters and profit-mad executives that are currently
making them.
Our current national health insurance program,
by comparison, is run by profit-driven insurance companies that
superimpose an incredibly huge financial layer on top of the
heath care organizations that actually provide the services.
This practice sucks 30 percent of the funding out of an industry
that could so much more effectively invest it in better services.
That $400 billion per year could actually cover the costs of
a single payer system.
A single-payer system is also good for businesses and their
employees. The company-provided insurance programs that most
Americans rely upon are disappearing as the current system's
escalating health care expenses are forcing businesses to cut
insurance costs and lay off workers.
Several countries, including the industrialized countries,
are already providing similar health care services and reporting
successful results. Taiwan passed a single-payer plan and within
a few years was able to provide health care for 90 to 95 percent
of its people.
Canada got rid of their health insurance industry in the 1970's.
They were spending the same percentage of their gross national
product as the US on health and had the same insurance companies.
They now provide what they call First Dollar Coverage for all
of their citizens. This means No Co-payment. No Deductible.
You go to any doctor, any time, any hospital in the country.
There is no cost for the patients.
They also offer a wider range of services, including dentistry,
and patients can choose their personal doctor. Tommy Douglas,
the man credited with creating the Canadian national health
program, was recently voted the greatest leader in Canadian
history.
Norway, which has been named the best to live for six years
in a row, not only provides free health care for its citizens,
it also offers free education at all levels and all ages for
its people.
Most European countries, including Great Britain, Germany and
the Netherlands offer universal coverage. Switzerland offers
universal coverage, all citizens pay the same amount and the
government covers those who can't afford to pay. France's health
care system is rated the best in the world. It offers universal
coverage, responsive health care providers, patient freedoms
and contributes to the longevity of the country's population.
A Harris poll conducted in the Fall of 2008 shows that only
one out of 14 Americans believe that the health insurance industry
is honest and trustworthy. That's about where all politicians
should rank, too. The health insurance industry has invested
so much money befriending members of Congress and heads of government
agencies over the years that our politicians don't even recognize
the possibility of health care without the insurance industry.
The insurance industry thrives by paying as little out as it
can, and pocketing as much as possible. The plan is to sign
up only the healthiest and wealthiest patients, charge them
more with large co-payments and huge deductibles, and deny care
to everybody else. The insurance companies are focusing on profits
to the point that they are denying health care services to people
who need them. They are excluding the elderly and people with
a prior illness or injury, problems that everybody will experience
at some point in their lives.
The people that suffer are the patients – the insurance
execs and stock holders actually profit from this.
In the past three decades the numbers of health administrators
in our system has increased 30 times more than doctors and nursing
positions. These people are not doctors. They're not nurses.
They're not pharmacists. They're not providing care. Many of
them are actually being paid to deny care.
What are the biggest barriers to the passage of a health care
system that provides needed care to all of our nations citizens?
Sidney Wolfe, MD, the president of Public Citizen and director
of it's Health Research Group, says it's “The power of
the health insurance industry.”
Dr. David Himmelstein, the Founder of the Physicians for a
National Health Program supports the single payer concept. In
a recent interview on PBS' Bill Moyers Journal he made the claim,
“You can't actually have a health care program that works,
if you keep the insurance industry alive.”
The American Medical Association, which proclaimed in 1968
that "Health care is not a right. -- it's a privilege"
is also an obstacle. The AMA supports this concept to this day,
despite a survey by the Physicians for a National Health Program
that shows a majority of doctors support the single payer health
care concept. The excessive paperwork and the bureaucracy involved
in dealing with the insurance companies takes up far to much
of their time.
But the largest barrier is our current political system, which
has grown dependent on financial contributions from special
interests. Money buys Washington. It owns Capitol Hill. The
private health insurance industry and the pharmaceutical industry,
which is also garnering huge profits from the lack of price
controls in our current system, are spending billions of dollars
on politicians. The biggest recipients are politicians at the
highest levels of political power, including the chairs of Congressional
committees who control which witnesses testify in public hearings.
President Obama believes a single-payer system makes sense,
but now says the problem in America is that we have an established
tradition of employer based health care and the president believes
switching to single-payer would be too disruptive. One sixth
of our economy would have to be overhauled.
Dr. Himmelstein says a single-payer system is not disruptive
for doctors, patients, nurses. It actually frees them these
people to do their work. It's only disruptive for executives
in the insurance industry who are used to making $225 thousand
a day. What is truly disruptive is when a tax paying citizen
loses his or her job and their health care and driven into bankruptcy.
What are the possibilities of our political leaders passing
single-payer bills in a Congress where our politicians are actually
afraid of the health insurance industry? They bow to them and
answer to them in the same way they treat Wall Street and the
banks. They're all receiving bailout money!
There are a few courageous Congressmen who are supporting single-payer
health care. Representative John Conyers, Jr., a Detroit Democrat
who is currently serving his twenty-second term in the House
of Representatives, has introduced HR676, a single-payer bill,
in Congress. Seventy-two members of the House are supporting
the bill.
Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders has introduced the American
Health Security Act of 2009, a single-payer bill, in the Senate.
This is the first single-payer bill introduced in the Senate
since the mid-1990s
The health care battle is a war being waged against the American
public by the health insurance industry. The American people
need to speak up and show our leaders that we mean business.
Participate in Demonstrations and support just causes.
Contact your Congressmen. Politicians are afraid of losing
elections and the financial fortunes typically garnered through
their political careers. Let them know you will vote against
them if they fail to support this issue.
Demand that our President, who reportedly received large amounts
of insurance money in his campaigns, and all members of Congress
serve the interests of the American people -- not the special
interests. We need a whole new attitude in our representatives
in Washington, people with courage as opposed to cowardice.
And support for the people – and not against them.
We need to Throw
The Bums Out of power.
Dave Satre
May 25th, 2009
All Commercial Rights Reserved
Links for More Info on this topic:
Physicians for a National Health Program
http://www.pnhp.org/
Public Citizen's Health Research Group
http://www.citizen.org/hrg/
John Conyers
http://www.johnconyers.com/hr676faq
The Nation
http://www.thenation.com/blogs/state_of_change/422538/sanders_puts_single_payer_on_the_agenda
Bill Moyers Journal
A Medical Dilemma
http://www.pbs.org/moyers/journal/05222009/profile2.html